The Future of Branding—Where Design Is Headed Next w/ Brian Collins
In a provocative conversation with Chris Do, design master Brian Collins declares the old model of branding is dead and reveals the future.
Chris Do
Founder, The Futur™ · October 6, 2024
The Old Model is Obsolete
Brian Collins, a man whose agency has been named Agency of the Year six times in six years, has a simple message: “The branding industry the way you knew it is dead. It’s gone.”
It’s a startling declaration from a designer who has shaped the visual and strategic landscapes of brands from Spotify and Disney to IBM and the Dove Campaign for Real Beauty. But for Collins, founder of the eponymous agency COLLINS, this isn’t pessimism. It’s a diagnosis.
After 16 years of proving his firm’s philosophy, he looked at the industry and saw a game that had run its course. “The Branding model the way everybody was was now dealing with it with these crazy ass case studies of people were pumping out almost once a month, that had run its course,” Collins tells Chris Do.
He saw an industry stuck in a loop, churning out visual artifacts while the world was demanding fundamental change. He decided the only way forward was to light a match. “We stuck dynamite in our old business model.”
Two seismic shifts are forcing this reckoning. First, the giants are coming. “Advertising agencies… are now getting in the brand and design game,” Collins warns. When the big holding companies, with their immense resources and scale, finally turn their attention to a sector, the existing models are rendered obsolete. They bring storytelling muscle and financial power that can hijack the conversation.
The second, and more profound, disruptor is artificial intelligence. Collins saw this coming years ago, speaking on this very platform about generative systems long before they became a mainstream topic. The AI you see today, he cautions, is the worst it will ever be. “You’re looking at the Model A of AI,” he explains. “We got from the Model A to the Moon in 60 years. It’s going to go twice as fast as that because the AI systems will be able to self-generate.”
The immediate consequence is the wholesale commoditization of image-making. The unique ability to create a beautiful image, the historical domain of the designer, will become instantaneous and nearly free. This reality strips away the low-level value proposition of many design firms, forcing a brutal question: if you’re not just making pretty pictures, what value do you actually bring?
The Dynamite Moment: A New Foundation
Facing this new reality, Collins and his co-founder, Leland Maschmeyer, used the mandatory pause of the COVID-19 pandemic to detonate their own company. It was an act of intentional reinvention, a search for what would come next.
They looked back over their 16 years of work, searching for the pattern in their most outsized successes. They weren’t looking for aesthetic trends. They were looking for the source code of their impact.
They distilled their findings into a new set of operating principles.
First, they reaffirmed a core belief: design is not what it looks like, but what it does. The visual identity is merely the result of a brand’s behavior and function. The outcome, not the artifact, is the primary goal.
Second, they redefined the very concept of brand. “Brand is not the typeface. Brand is not the color. Brand is not the logo,” Collins insists. “What brand is, is differentiation. And differentiation is about making sure you do not become a commodity.” This shifts the focus from aesthetics to strategic market positioning.
This led to their third and most critical realization: the business they were truly in. If a company isn’t one step ahead of culture, it will be left behind. This means companies must constantly change, constantly evolve. Therefore, the most valuable service one can offer is not communication or graphic design. “The business that we were actually in was in the transformation business,” Collins states. “Helping companies transform so they could build a better future that was a step ahead of the culture.”
By embracing this, they moved from being vendors of branding to partners in business evolution. They weren’t just creating brand systems; they were designing new futures. This is the essence of what Collins calls Transformation Design.
Desert Power: The Rise of the Un-Community
With a new model in place, COLLINS shifted its focus from external fanfare to internal and communal substance. The old game of chasing awards and speaking slots—what a mentor once told Collins was creating a “little halo” about oneself—was no longer the priority.
Instead, they began building something quieter and more potent: community.
It started with an experiment called Coffee House. They opened their New York studio doors, offering free coffee, pastries, and a space for conversation. No agenda, no speakers, no pitches. The first time, 250 people showed up just to talk. The next event drew 300. It became clear they had tapped into a deep, unmet need for genuine connection, unburdened by commercial intent.
The principle was simple: “There’s no strangers, it’s just friends you haven’t met yet.” Collins and his team would actively nurture the environment, introducing introverts, sparking conversations, and even climbing the ladders of their famous 5,500-book library to find the perfect volume for a guest struggling with a specific problem. Someone likened it to Ollivanders Wand Shop from Harry Potter, a place where the right knowledge finds you.
This philosophy reached its apex at the Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity. Collins describes the modern festival as having been “hijacked by these giant pavilions”—massive, loud, corporate behemoths blasting techno music along the waterfront. He saw a system dominated by what Frank Herbert, in his novel Dune, might call Harkonnen power: brute force, scale, and control.
COLLINS opted for what Herbert called Desert Power: organic, responsive, anticipatory, and poetic.
They rented an 1866 chateau in the hills above Cannes, a serene oasis 12 minutes from the chaos. For four days, they hosted free, informal gatherings. They invited their heroes and friends—influential figures like Scott Galloway, Cindy Gallop, and Michael Kassan—alongside young, unknown designers from Glasgow. The only rule for entry: you had to take off your lanyard.
“When you walk around in Cannes, everyone has these lanyards,” Collins explains. “It has your name, it has your title, and has the brand that you're with.” By forcing people to remove them, they stripped away the hierarchy. “It wasn’t about your position, your title, your prestige, your power. It was, do you have imagination? What’s the quality of your thinking? What’s the generosity of your spirit?”
The result was electric. People had real conversations. Epiphanies happened on staircases and over glasses of wine, not in darkened auditoriums. The response was so overwhelming that a rival global agency, which had just won a major award, called and asked to host their celebration at the COLLINS chateau. It was the ultimate validation: in a world saturated with programming, the most valuable commodity is unstructured space for human connection. As Collins puts it, building a truly effective personal and corporate brand today is about creating these authentic spaces.
The New Language of Value: Where Finance Meets Art
To power this new model of transformation, COLLINS had to become fluent in a language many designers avoid: finance.
“We had to break a lot of our preconceptions about what we thought was design and what wasn’t,” Collins admits. “We realized now that Finance is design, business strategy is design, management consulting is design.”
This wasn't about designers becoming accountants. It was about recognizing a shared purpose. Finance, at its best, is a creative discipline. Its mission is to identify the biggest areas of opportunity for a business to grow. “Finance will help you find that, and that is what’s most viable,” he explains. Art and design, meanwhile, excel at imagining what the future could look like, or what is most desirable. These two pursuits are not opposed; they are two sides of the same coin, both trying to anticipate what’s over the horizon.
To bridge this gap, COLLINS brought in strategic thinkers with backgrounds from firms like McKinsey and MBAs from Stanford and Harvard. These team members could speak with authority to CEOs and CFOs about financial analysis, market viability, and portfolio strategy. This gave the firm a dual fluency.
They could now hold two critical conversations simultaneously:
- The C-Suite Conversation: A dialogue with CEOs and CFOs about growth, relevance, and outsized business opportunity, backed by rigorous financial and market analysis.
- The Creative Conversation: A dialogue with Chief Creative and Marketing Officers about differentiation through design, copy, film, and culture, backed by deep craft and aesthetic competence.
This integration demystifies the creative process for business leaders and grounds creative work in measurable outcomes. Collins discovered that the imagined wall between “creatives” and “business people” is nonsense. He recalls moderating a discussion with Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz and finding common ground in stories of belonging, or befriending a world-famous political scientist who secretly loved The Muppets. “Somehow we think people who work in finance or business… they were kids too,” he says. “The hard line that creative people often put between people who are business people and creative people is nonsense.” This approach to finding a niche and combining disciplines is a powerful way to turn your passion into profit.
Putting It All Together: The Legions Story
So what does Transformation Design look like in practice? Collins offers the story of Therma Holdings, a company based in the Midwest and California.
Blackstone, the private equity giant, had invested in this sprawling collection of what Collins calls “wrench-turning heating, air conditioning, pump, water” businesses. These companies were highly skilled at managing HVAC systems but were poorly branded and perceived as a commodity service. They were growing, but without a unified purpose or story.
Blackstone’s challenge to COLLINS was straightforward: what do we do with all these companies?
The initial framing was about energy reduction. But Collins immediately saw the flaw. “No one’s going to want a reduction story,” he says. “Business wants a maximization story.”
The COLLINS team, including its financial and portfolio analysts, dug deep. They discovered a crucial fact: the biggest source of carbon emissions in the world isn't from cars, but from buildings. The disparate companies under the Therma Holdings umbrella were, collectively, experts at making buildings more efficient. They had engineered the first zero-carbon hospital and the first zero-carbon airport. They just didn't have the language to articulate their own significance.
The insight was profound. They weren’t in the business of reducing energy; they were in the business of maximizing building efficiency on a global scale. This was the story that could transform them from a collection of service providers into a world-changing force.
With this new narrative, the name Therma Holdings no longer fit. COLLINS rebranded them as **Legions**. The name evoked strength, scale, and a unified mission. The rebrand wasn't just a new logo and a website; it was a re-articulation of the company’s soul.
The business exploded. The new story resonated internally with thousands of employees and externally with a market hungry for solutions to the climate crisis.
This process highlights the power of finding a story that connects a company’s core competency to a larger human ambition. It also reveals Collins’s disdain for the traditional design presentation. He calls the common practice of showing three options—one safe, one wild, one in the middle—insane. “Everyone does Goldilocks,” he scoffs. “This is too hot, this is too soft… and everyone goes right to the middle.” This process guarantees mediocrity and eliminates the chance for a transformative leap.
Instead, COLLINS identifies a client's core values—for instance, efficiency, speed, or reassurance—and builds a singular strategic and creative path forward based on the most potent value. The conversation becomes about the future you want to build, not which shade of yellow you prefer. When the core ambition is articulated correctly, the emotional resonance is unmistakable. “I’ve seen it make a CEO cry,” Collins reveals. After reading a new brand ambition to a founder, the man teared up. “That’s the reason I started this company… and no one’s ever ever put it into language.”
That is the power of real language. And it is something that requires deep listening, as taught in The Art of Listening & Communication.
Your Job is to Rehearse the Future
For Collins, the path forward is clear. He is not interested in being the best branding agency. “I’m not interested in being the best or better or the leader,” he states. “I’m interested in being the only.”
This means constantly evolving. He traces the lineage of his profession: from Commercial Art to Graphic Design, to Communication Design, to Corporate Identity, to Branding. Each term encompassed and transcended the one before it. For COLLINS, the next great leap is to Transformation Design.
He draws inspiration from visionaries who created new models rather than fighting the old ones. Standing near his home in Woods Hole, Massachusetts is the very first geodesic dome, built by Buckminster Fuller, who famously said, “You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.”
He also points to Walt Disney as a master of transformation. In the 1950s, long before NASA existed, Disney was fascinated by space travel. To normalize the idea, he created a stunning film about a trip to the moon and placed a massive TWA-branded Moonliner rocket in the center of Tomorrowland. He didn't just entertain; he socialized a new future. He made the idea of space travel so irresistible that it became inevitable. The Eisenhower White House even called his studio asking for a copy of the film.
This, Collins argues, is the true superpower of the designer. “Designers ultimately rehearse the future before it arrives,” he says. “We’re like wizards. We can imagine any potential future before they arrive.”
The challenge for every creative professional today is to stop playing a game that is already over. The value is no longer in the artifact, the pretty image, or the slick case study.
The value lies in your ability to synthesize, to see patterns, to connect disparate ideas, and to articulate a new, more compelling future. It’s about having conversations that matter, with or without an agenda, and building a community that believes in the same future you do.
Stop trying to win the old game. Build a new one.
TRANSCRIPT
Enjoyed this? There’s more where it came from.
Get insights on creativity, business, and design from The Futur.
You can unsubscribe anytime. By submitting, you agree to receive communications and to our Privacy Policy.
“The branding industry the way you knew it is dead.”
— Chris Do
Key Takeaways
Subscribe
Details
- Length
- 1h 3m
- Views
- 74,745
- Topic
- BRAND STRATEGY